Scott Griffiths on behalf of the entire Ashwabay Alliance Board
Greetings Friends and Neighbors,
I am writing this letter to the community that has grown around Mt. Ashwabay and Big Top Chautauqua over decades. A community that has given through financial contributions, volunteerism, patronage, manual labor, ticket sales, tent raisings, and ski races. A community that has received countless gifts of music, laughter, camaraderie, fun and magic. I grew up here. My introduction to Mt. Ashwabay was as a high school ski racer in the late 80s, then again as a ski coach after college. I learned the history of this region through shows like Souvenir Views, Riding the Wind, and Keeper of the Light, and I have experienced the magic of world-class musicians under the canvas and under the stars. Since my early adolescence, this place has been an integral and formative part of my life.
I joined the board at the beginning of this summer and was elected board president in October. When I was invited to join the board “to bring some new energy and perspective,” there was real hope that the 2026 Big Top season would help turn things around. Even with a record-breaking crowd for Trampled by Turtles, it unfortunately did not. The board and staff have worked tirelessly to find a sustainable path forward for the Big Top.
The press releases we have shared this fall were our attempt to be honest without causing undue panic while we considered every option at our disposal. That work has been done, and it is now my duty to share with you the unpleasant reality that successive boards have been reckoning with for the past few years. The Ashwabay Alliance does not have a sustainable path forward, and will not be able to produce a summer season in 2027 or beyond. On November 10, the board approved a motion to “develop an orderly wind-down plan, including a timetable, treatment of creditors and contracts, and consideration of dissolution or other legally appropriate alternatives.” The plan will then need to return to the board for further action and final approval.
HOW WE GOT HERE
Investment, Losses, Rising Costs and Changes in the Industry
After years of deliberation, the boards of Ashwabay and the Big Top both decided that merging was the most viable path to long-term sustainability. It was not an easy decision, and not everyone involved believed it was the right one. The merger brought together two organizations with very different cultures. The merger was legally finalized on February 14, 2022, and there were several tumultuous years while the two organizations learned to function as one. Some people were let go, some new people were hired, and positions were combined to create year-round employment in place of seasonal jobs at the Big Top in summer and at the hill in winter. Wages were increased to keep pace with the rising cost of living on the peninsula since the pandemic. These were good-faith and necessary efforts to invest in our team, and they also significantly raised the combined organization’s fixed costs. At the same time, insurance nearly doubled, and inflation has hit this organization as hard as it has hit your family.
Revenue and fundraising faced pressure too. Over the years Mt. Ashwabay and BTC received enormous support from Mary Rice and other generous contributors. With Mary’s passing we lost one of our largest donors, who regularly helped close the financial gap at the end of challenging years. The music industry has changed: artist fees have risen dramatically, and ticket prices have climbed with them.This year alone ticket sales, our largest revenue stream, were less 60% of what was projected. Small venues around the country are closing their doors and crowds have not returned to where they were before COVID. Here on the peninsula, live music has flourished due, in no small part, to the influence of the Big Top. When the tent opened 40 years ago, it was one of the only places in northern Wisconsin to hear live music. Today, there is live music almost any night of the week, year-round, and the caliber of musicianship in our region rivals communities far larger than ours.
Press coverage has mentioned a loss of more than $800,000 in fiscal year 2025. That is not the whole story. This organization has been on this trajectory since the pandemic. The Alliance’s 990 tax filings, which are public (and can be found here) show the trend. The last year without a significant loss was 2022. That year, people were thrilled to return to live events after the COVID shutdowns. Additionally, the Alliance received more than $700,000 in government pandemic relief.
But since then:
- Calendar year 2023: a loss of $486,109
- January through September 2024: a loss of $336,898 (this is the year that Ashwabay and Big Top’s Fiscal years merged, so the “year” was 9 months)
- October 2024 through September 2025: a loss of $888,610
- October 2025 through September 2026 (internal, unaudited): a loss of about $1.1 million
That is a total loss of about $2.81 million since January 2023. Pandemic grant relief, years of generous fundraising and successful seasons built reserves that carried the Alliance through the first years of those losses. However, those reserves are now gone.
The causes for these losses will undoubtedly be litigated in comment sections, coffee shops, and dining rooms for the foreseeable future. “They booked the wrong shows,” “They ran too many shows,” “The ticket prices were too high,” “They didn’t run enough shows,” “They hired the wrong people,” “They fired the wrong people.” There are certainly kernels of truth in these statements. The Alliance tried new leadership within the board and staff. The Alliance tried different genres of music and different numbers of shows. The Backstage was purchased and remodeled in an effort to centralize operations near the hill and provide more opportunities for the Blue Canvas Orchestra to share their gifts. More marketing staff was added as well as a new outside firm to expand regional marketing efforts. The Alliance tried a new year-round venue with lower ticket prices at StageNorth. The Alliance tried new food, drinks and flow in the cafe. Some of these experiments were well-received, while some failed. None of them moved the needle far enough or fast enough to change the trajectory.
Over the years, many trusted, generous and capable people, on staff and on the board, have given their time, skills, and resources to keep this well-loved organization on track. They gave it their best. Unfortunately, it has not been enough. The Alliance board of directors bears the ultimate responsibility for the current state of affairs. The Alliance’s cash reserves are depleted. We have laid off a large portion of our staff to buy time to find solutions, but have come up empty-handed. We are preparing to sell assets, including the Backstage. We are in early talks with Bayfield County to sell acreage to them so that existing CAMBA trails can stay open. Forecasts suggest another winter with very little snow, but our dedicated, greatly-reduced team is diligently preparing for a winter recreation season.
The Keepers
For more than a decade, over 100 people gave to the Keepers fund, and those gifts built a reserve of roughly $1M. To keep operations going over the last two years, the Alliance drew on that reserve in two ways. In 2025, $480,000 was leveraged as collateral for a line of credit, and in August of 2026, these funds were tapped directly to support operations. Before this action was taken, two law firms were engaged and each offered the opinion that these funds were board-restricted, and therefore available for the board to use at their discretion. A law firm representing a number of those donors has since written a letter to the Alliance and the Wisconsin Attorney General’s office asserting that the fund is donor-restricted, meaning that the money can only be used for specific, donor-intended uses, which they assert does not include operating expenses. The Attorney General’s office is reviewing the documents that have been provided by the Alliance and by the donors. Until the AG rules, the Alliance is not able to utilize the funds. Depending on how the AG rules, the Alliance may need to make that fund whole. The organization has no intention, nor does it have the resources, to litigate this. The Alliance has asked the Attorney General for a decision and for guidance on how to proceed, and those instructions will be followed. The Keepers’ letter, the Attorney General’s letter, and the Alliance’s response are available here. It should be unequivocally stated that the Alliance is extraordinarily grateful for the financial support that was generously contributed over the years by this group of donors.
The Keepers fund was the final cash reserve available to maintain operations. At this point, even if the fund were fully available, it would not fix the structural problem. As it stands, the Alliance has about $100,000 remaining to cover payroll and expenses until we see revenue from the ski season. Beyond that, there is nothing left.
Our goal through all of this is to meet our obligations to the staff, musicians, vendors, and lenders who have given so much to this organization, and to leave no unresolved debt.
WHAT THE BOARD HAS DECIDED
After months of deliberation, countless hours buried in financial spreadsheets and many, many conversations with people who have been intimately involved with this organization for years, the board has come to the following decisions.
The Alliance will NOT produce a summer 2027 Big Top season. We are heartbroken to have to share this news, but it is the reality in which we find ourselves. Even if the Alliance were to receive significant fundraising support, we see no viable path to a 2027 summer season or beyond. The last four years of significant losses have led us to the conclusion that we no longer have a sustainable business model for Big Top Chautauqua.
Winding down the Alliance and Big Top Chautauqua. We have begun to work with our attorney and a nonprofit consulting group to consider what an orderly wind-down of the Ashwabay Alliance would look like. A final decision to dissolve the organization has not yet been made, but it appears that we can either proactively take these steps in an orderly fashion or it will happen to us in a disorderly fashion. That means selling what we need to sell, paying what we owe, and resolving the contracts and agreements we have with vendors, creditors and the musicians of the Blue Canvas Orchestra. The final decision regarding the future of the Ashwabay Alliance also depends on the Attorney General’s decision regarding the Keepers fund, and we do not yet know that answer.
A path forward for Mt. Ashwabay. Recreation is the part of this organization with a path to sustainability, and the community support for it is already emerging. Recreation revenue has been increasing. In a typical year, the ski hill’s shortfall is small enough for fundraising and grants to close. The ski hill itself is owned by the Ashwabay Outdoor Educational Foundation (AOEF), the nonprofit that operated the hill before the merger and has held the land for years. The board is working with legal counsel to explore all of our options with the likely possibility that the ski hill operations will continue under the AOEF moving forward.
The launch of a $250,000 fundraising campaign to help run the 2026-27 ski season. Mt. Ashwabay covers most of its own operating costs, but this season starts with almost no cash. We are asking the community to raise $250,000 to open the season and carry it through this bridge year. We have donors that have indicated that they are ready to help Mt. Ashwabay kickstart this campaign. Your support would be greatly appreciated. The campaign launches soon, and gifts will go to support Mt. Ashwabay through the AOEF (not through the Ashwabay Alliance). If we fall short, we may need to make adjustments for a reduced-season.
What this means for you:
- Tickets to Killer Queen. If you purchased tickets to see Killer Queen this summer, we have every intention of providing a refund for those tickets. At this moment cash is short until we liquidate real-estate to cover these liabilities. If you are able to postpone your refund request, your patience would be appreciated.
- Season passes: We have every intention of running a winter recreation season as planned and would genuinely appreciate your show of support to Mt. Ashwabay through your purchase of a season pass. If the weather does not allow us to have enough snow to open in time for the Holiday Break this will add a significant financial burden to our rapidly dwindling resources.
- Gifts: gifts to the ski season campaign will be used to operate Mt Ashwabay.
We are holding a community information session on Tuesday, November 17, from 6 to 8 pm at the Backstage. This session will be livestreamed and available for viewing after the livestream has ended. This will be our opportunity to share this difficult message with the community directly and to answer your questions.
Closing
Sometimes one chapter has to end before the next can be written. The Ashwabay Alliance in its current form may be winding down, but the tent that has been the home to Big Top Chautauqua still lives at the base of Mt. Ashwabay. The musicians that have filled the tent with music are still part of our community. The music, the stories, the memories and the people who filled it will always be part of this place. If there is a group, a partner, or a new idea that wants to pick up where we leave off, we would love to talk with you. We cannot promise what comes next, but we will leave the door open to new possibilities.
Whatever comes next, this community has built something truly remarkable. To the staff, artists, volunteers, and donors who have given so much of themselves to this grand endeavor: thank you. I am sorry it has come to this. While my tenure with the Ashwabay Alliance is new, I can tell you that I am committed to working with this board and the staff team to move through this transition with honesty and integrity.
Sincerely,
Scott Griffiths, Board President
On behalf of the Ashwabay Alliance Board of Directors
Coke Lindsey- VP
Jim Miller- Treasurer
Dominic Papatola- Secretary
Mark Ehlers
Chuck Finn
Cara Overland
John Thiel
Kristen Walczak